Popular Hindi films place emotion and sentiment above complex characterisations, and writer Karan Johar's latest continues this tradition with relish. But while Johar's previous efforts (Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham, Kuch Kuch Hota Hai) have left audiences in tears, debutant director Nikhil Advani merits praise for tackling themes of family, emotion and love in a more jovial manner.
Shah Rukh Khan is chief among the film's plus points, playing the charismatic Aman, who attempts to reignite happiness in put-upon Naina's (Zinta) life. Though Johar's shadow looms large over it, the film breaks from the weepie format and compels us to share Aman's vitality for life in an unreserved climax.